Mutual Funds Commodities Research Tax Planning IPO Our Team Contact Us    

| More

Banking Sector Thematic Report - Down cycle stress testing - HDFC Securities

Posted On: 2020-06-28 18:09:28

Mr. Darpin Shah, Institutional Research Analyst, HDFC Securities.

Banking Sector Thematic Report: Down cycle stress testing

Even as the nationwide lockdown gradually lifts, there is more than enough evidence to suggest that the economic impact of COVID-19 is set to continue. Contextually, for banks, liability franchises and potential asset quality outcomes have come to be of paramount importance, and rightly so. In our earlier note, entitled 'Double whammy for some', we focussed on the liabilities' aspect.

While the moratorium will optically limit GNPAs till 1HFY21E, asset quality deterioration is inevitable. As the situation remains extremely fluid, we've analysed FY21 earnings under 4 scenarios (increasing segment wise NPA and PCR estimates) to evaluate the potential downside risks.

Under the most extreme scenario (IV), ABVs fall by 3-22% and ROAAs fall by 25-70bps. SBIN and KVB are the most vulnerable, as both report losses under scenario III and IV. Across parameters and scenarios, KMB performs the best (lowest dip in ABVs and healthy RoAAs).

Mid-tier private banks and SBIN, under our base case, trade at close to trough valuations and factor in scenario I/II to a certain extent. However, banks such as ICICIBC, AXSB, KMB and CUBK trade at a premium to their previous down cycle valuations.

We believe, that current valuations across our coverage do not adequately capture potential downside risks to earnings under scenario III & IV, especially after the recent run up. It is difficult to assign probabilities to individual scenarios. However, we believe, it is evident that across scenarios, banks with healthy B/S (CRAR, PCR and liability franchises) are well placed to absorb shocks.

Consequently, we continue to prefer large private banks such as ICICIBC (SoTP of Rs 442) and AXSB (SoTP of Rs 541). SBIN (SoTP of Rs 270), too, offers a favourable risk reward trade-off, despite its earnings vulnerability. Amongst the mid-tier banks we prefer CUBK (TP of Rs 164).

The results of our analysis are as follows:

Asset quality: Under various scenarios, we project a relatively greater increase in NPAs in the services/ SME and retail/ personal loan segments. Book mix is an important driver. Consequently, banks with a higher proportion of such loans see a greater increase in GNPAs. AUBANK, DCBB, FB and IIB report the greatest increase in GNPAs across scenarios, while KMB reports the lowest increase.

LPs: Our provision estimates under various scenarios have multiple drivers. Under the most extreme scenario (IV), we expect that majority of our coverage banks will see provisions rise by more than 45%. The base effect results in some anomalous trends- ICICIBC registers a 62.8% rise in FY21E LLPs and RBK sees a mere 22.9% rise, under scenario IV.

Earnings: Banks report the greatest variability on this parameter on a/c of high sensitivity to LLPs. SBIN, KVB and RBK report the greatest decline in earnings across scenarios, with SBIN and KVB reporting losses under scenario III and IV. KMB is the best placed on this front, as earnings dip 17.7% and RoAAs reach ~1.4%, even under scenario IV. AUBANK reports 1%+ RoAA, even under scenario IV.

CRAR: Even under scenario IV, our coverage banks see their CRAR fall between 31-69bps, with KMB reporting the lowest fall and SBIN reporting the highest. Almost all remain fairly well capitalised, even under scenario IV.

Source: Equity Bulls

Click here to send ur comments or to

Disclaimer:The article above is a gist / extract of the original report prepared by the research firm / brokerage firm. This article is not to be considered as an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any securities. This article is meant for general information only., its employees or owners or the research firms, its employees or owners won't be responsible for any liability that may arise from information, errors or omissions in these articles. or its employees or owners / the research firms or its employees or clients or owners may from time to time hold positions in securities referred in this article. For detailed research reports, please contact the concerned research firm directly.

Other Headlines:

Tata Consultancy Services - Q1FY21 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Arvind Fashions - Company Update - ICICI Securities

Result Preview - Telecom - ICICI Securities

Result Preview - Banking & Financial Services - ICICI Securities

1QFY21 Results Preview for Banks & NBFC's - A washout quarter - HDFC Securities

Maintain REDUCE on Tata Consultancy Services - Positives factored in - HDFC Securities

National Aluminium - Quant Pick - ICICI Securities

Cement - Q1FY21 Result Preview - ICICI Securities

Consumer Discretionary - Q1FY21 Result Preview - ICICI Securities

Paints - Dealer Check - July 2020 - ICICI Securities

Auto and auto ancillary - Q1FY21 Result Preview - ICICI Securities

Real Estate (Sector Update) - Greenshoots visible - HDFC Securities

Cement (Sector Update) - Prices, retail sales hold up despite COVID - HDFC Securities

TCI Express - Branch economics, cost levers as margin tailwinds - ICICI Securities

Mishra Dhatu Nigam - Space order inflow may slow down in FY21 - ICICI Securities

Century Plyboards - Compelling BUY; top pick in building materials - ICICI Securities

Building material - Sector Update - ICICI Securities

ISGEC Heavy Engineering - On a strong footing despite macro headwinds - ICICI Securities

Telecom - Growth breaks due to Covid-19 crisis - ICICI Securities

Pfizer Ltd - Company Update - ICICI Securities

Petronet LNG - Quant Pick - ICICI Securities

Earnings Wrap Q4FY20: Quarter end lockdown takes toll, one-offs rule Q4FY20

Autos & Transportation Sector Update Report - Focus on '3Cs' - HDFC Securities

Banking Sector Credit Trends - Weakness building - HDFC Securities

India Equity Strategy Report - Back to pre-covid levels - HDFC Securities

Strategy: Cyclicals to lead earnings recovery over FY20-22 - ICICI Securities

JK Cement - Ripe for re-rating - ICICI Securities

Phillips Carbon Black - Company Update - ICICI Securities

Information Technology - Q1FY21 Result Preview - ICICI Securities

Motherson Sumi Systems Ltd - Company Update - ICICI Securities

HDFC Ltd - Quant Pick - ICICI Securities

Auto Sales Data for June 2020 - Angel Broking

FMCG - Sector Review 4QFY20 - Disruption visible, growth divergence increases - HDFC Securities

Maintain ADD on ONGC - Impairment loss drags earnings - HDFC Securities

Maintain BUY on Ahluwalia Contracts - Looking ahead - HDFC Securities

RIL-Intel Deal - Angel Broking

Strategy: 'Out of turn' change in NIFTY50 due to Vedanta delisting - ICICI Securities

Time Technoplast - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Monthly Auto Volumes - July 2020 - ICICI Securities

Oil & Natural Gas Corporation - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Minda Industries - Q4 FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Auto Sales - June 2020 - Acuité Ratings & Research

Bharat Electronics - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Petronet LNG - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Tata Steel - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Phoenix Mills - Q4FY20 Result Update - ICICI Securities

Jun-20 Volumes expectations: Sales to rise over 2x from May-20 levels for Hero, Maruti - HDFC Securities

Maintain REDUCE on RBL Bank - Risks more evident - HDFC Securities

Maintain ADD on Subros - Expect market share gains to continue - HDFC Securities

Maintain ADD on Petronet LNG - One offs in opex drag profitability - HDFC Securities

Website Created & Maintained by : Chennai Scripts
West Mambalam, Chennai - 600 033,
Tamil Nadu, India

disclaimer copyright © 2005 - 2019